Choosing Between Brick, Block, and Stone for Your Next Build
If you’re a New Jersey homeowner planning a patio, walkway, retaining wall, or exterior upgrade, you’ve probably already hit the big question: Should you build with brick, block, or stone? Each material looks different, performs differently in NJ’s freeze-thaw climate, and comes with its own price tag, and choosing wrong can cost thousands and lead to repairs you never budgeted for. That’s where having a team like Pete’s Concrete & Masonry makes the decision a whole lot easier. With decades of hands-on experience across Morris, Essex, Union, and Passaic Counties, Pete and his crew guide homeowners toward materials that actually fit their budget, design goals, and long-term durability needs.
Why the Material Matters More Than Most Homeowners Realize
Too many homeowners choose a material solely based on looks. Then winter hits, moisture expands inside the joints, and suddenly that “Pinterest-perfect” wall or walkway begins to shift, crack, or discolor.
Different materials perform very differently in New Jersey’s climate, specifically because of:
- Repeated freeze-thaw cycles.
- Soil movement.
- Moisture and drainage issues.
- Load-bearing requirements.
Choosing correctly isn’t just about beauty. It’s about lifespan and long-term costs.
Brick — The Classic, Timeless Option for NJ Homes
Brick has been used for centuries because it balances charm, function, and durability. In towns like Montclair, Morristown, and Bloomfield, brick blends naturally with older architecture.
Pros of Brick
- Timeless curb appeal — works beautifully for patios, walkways, facades, and fireplaces.
- Good durability — handles NJ winters well with proper installation.
- Energy-efficient — thermal mass helps regulate indoor temperatures.
- Fire-resistant — ideal for outdoor kitchens or fire features.
Cons of Brick
- Costs more than a block (Avg. ~$60 per sq. Meter installed).
- Requires skilled bricklayers for proper joint alignment.
- Mortar joints may need repointing over time.
Best Uses
- Walkways
- Patio borders
- Fireplaces
- Home facades
- Garden features
Concrete Block — The Budget-Friendly, High-Strength Choice
Concrete block (CMU) is the unsung hero of masonry work. It’s the least glamorous but often the most essential.
Pros of Concrete Block
- Lowest cost — roughly $10 per sq. meter for materials.
- Fast installation — larger units mean lower labor costs.
- Excellent strength — great for retaining walls and foundations.
- Fire-resistant and moisture-resistant.
Cons of Concrete Block
- More utilitarian appearance.
- Often requires stucco, paint, or veneer to look finished.
- It can feel too industrial for some residential projects.
Best Uses
- Retaining walls
- Foundations
- Large commercial or industrial projects.
- Structural walls need reinforcement.
Stone — The High-End, Luxury Material for NJ Homes
Natural stone is the showstopper. If you’ve ever driven through Mendham, Harding, or Summit and admired those stunning stone walls, you know exactly what we mean.
Pros of Stone
- Unmatched longevity — stone can last centuries.
- Unique look — no two pieces are the same.
- Minimal maintenance — highly resistant to weather, fire, pests, and moisture.
- Premium curb appeal — instantly elevates home value.
Cons of Stone
- Highest cost — quarrying and installation requires specialists.
- Slower installation time.
- Heavyweight may require reinforced bases.
Best Uses
- Retaining walls.
- Luxury patios.
- Exterior facades.
- Decorative accents.
- Steps, pillars, and landscape features.
How to Choose the Right Material for YOUR NJ Project
Step 1 — Identify Your Budget
If you’re trying to keep costs tight, concrete block usually wins. On the other hand, if you want a balance between beauty and affordability, brick is ideal. If you’re building a forever-home, stone offers unmatched value.
Step 2 — Consider Your Aesthetic Goals
Ask yourself:
- Do you want something natural and rustic? Then stone is the best choice.
- Something classic and coordinated? Brick would be the better option.
- Something functional and easy to finish? Go with block.
Step 3 — Evaluate NJ Climate Factors
Freeze-thaw cycles are no joke here.
- Stone handles the elements best.
- Brick performs extremely well when joints are properly installed.
- The block needs finishing to protect it from surface wear.
Step 4 — Think About Structural Needs
Load-bearing? Retaining soil? Supporting a patio? Block is usually the most structurally efficient. Brick and stone often serve decorative or non-load-bearing roles unless engineered properly.
Step 5 — Consult With a Professional Mason
Even the “cheapest” option becomes expensive if installed incorrectly. This is where Pete’s team shine. They don’t just ask what material you want. They ask:
- What’s the soil doing?
- How will drainage affect it?
- What’s the long-term maintenance?
- Will this survive 10 NJ winters or 50?
Pete himself often visits the property to ensure the material matches the environment, not just the idea in someone’s head.
Comparison Table
| Feature | Brick | Concrete Block | Stone |
| Aesthetic | Classic, uniform | Industrial, can be finished | Natural, rugged, premium |
| Cost | Mid-range | Lowest | Highest |
| Durability | Very high | High (load-bearing strength) | Exceptional |
| Maintenane | Low | Moderate | Very low |
| Installation | Skilled labor | Fast and efficient | Specialized labor |
| Best For | Homes, facades, walkways | Foundations, retaining walls | Luxury features, exterior walls |
Which Material Is “Best”?
Brick is best when you want a timeless look, great durability, and moderate cost. Block is best for strength, affordability, and large structural projects. Stone is best for unmatched beauty, longevity, and high-end outdoor spaces.
There is no universally “right” choice, only the right material for your specific project, budget, and environment.
When in Doubt, Let Pete’s Concrete & Masonry Guide You
If this feels overwhelming, you’re not alone. Most homeowners don’t choose masonry materials every day. That’s exactly why Pete’s Concrete & Masonry walks you through the pros, cons, and real-world performance of each option before a single block or brick is laid.
Whether you’re planning a new patio, walkway, driveway, or retaining wall, their team brings the craftsmanship, honesty, and local experience that New Jersey homeowners trust.
Call 201-674-1827 to get expert guidance, or request a consultation directly through the website.
